Giving a Knife as a Gift and a Penny: Tradition, Meaning, and Etiquette
Knives are timeless, practical, and beautiful gifts. From kitchen knives to folding pocket knives, they represent strength, craftsmanship, and utility. But if you've ever heard the superstition that gifting knives is bad luck, you may also know about the unique tradition of giving a knife as a gift and a penny.
So what does this really mean? Let's delve into the origins, superstitions, and proper etiquette surrounding the gift of knives.
The Superstition About Giving Knives
Throughout history, many cultures have believed in a knife gift superstition. According to old traditions, if you give a knife as a gift without a coin, it could "cut" the friendship or relationship between giver and receiver.
This belief explains why some people ask: "Is it bad luck to give knives as a gift?" or "Is it bad luck to gift a knife?" The answer depends on cultural traditions, but many still follow this superstition today.
Why Do You Give a Coin with a Knife?
To avoid bad luck, people began adding a coin—often a penny—to a gift of a knife. The recipient then returns the coin to the giver as "payment." This simple exchange turns the knife from a gift into a transaction, protecting the relationship from being "cut."
This explains the tradition of:
- Giving a penny with a knife
- Giving a coin with a knife
- Knife and coin gifts
The practice remains popular, not only as a superstition but also as a thoughtful tradition that adds meaning to the gift.
A Knife and No Coin Meaning
So what if you give a knife and no coin? In traditional belief, this could symbolise bad luck, a broken friendship, or a strained relationship. While many people today view it as just folklore, others still take it seriously. To be safe, it's better to include a coin and honour the tradition.
Etiquette When Giving a Knife as a Gift
If you want to gift a knife but still respect tradition, here are some tips:
- Always Include a Coin – Slip a penny, nickel, or small coin in the knife box or sheath.
- Explain the Tradition – Tell the recipient, "It’s tradition to return the coin to me, so the knife doesn’t cut our friendship."
- Choose the Right Knife – Select a knife that suits the person: a chef's knife for cooking enthusiasts, a hunting knife for outdoorspeople, or a folding pocket knife for everyday use.
By following these steps, you respect the tradition of giving an old knife as a gift while also providing a meaningful and useful present.
Giving Knives as Gifts Today
While the old beliefs remain, many people now see knives as practical, elegant, and personal gifts. Whether it's for a wedding, birthday, or Father's Day, giving knives is a thoughtful gesture—especially when personalised with engraving on the blade, handle, or sheath.
Still, the custom of giving knives and a penny continues, passed down as both superstition and sentiment. Even if you don't believe in bad luck, adding a coin makes the gift more special.
Final Thoughts
Is it considered bad luck to gift a knife? According to superstition, yes—but only if you forget the coin. That's why people still follow the tradition of giving a knife as a gift, along with a penny. It's a small but meaningful gesture that protects the bond between giver and receiver.
Whether you believe in the superstition of gifting knives or love the tradition of giving knives, the important part is the thought behind the gift. A knife, paired with a penny, becomes not just a tool but a symbol of respect, care, and enduring connection.
